Some additional advantages to 16" - they cost less - larger wheels are heavier, much more difficult to rotate yourself, much better ride.
There is currently a regrettable trend to larger wheels for styling.
Personally, for me the 16 inch wheel look much more appropriate, practical and stylish on the NIRO.
We have another vehicle (Santa FE SEL FWD) with 17 inch wheels and it almost takes a professional weightlifter to rotate the wheels. Would much prefer 16-inch wheels on this vehicle.
Wait till you have to buy a 4 set replacement for low profile tires - holy cow -$$$$.
What Are Low-Profile Tires? Understanding The Pros And Cons | CarBuzz
I've been doing quite a bit of research in my quest to switch my 18" Alloy's to 16" Alloy's. I saw a beautiful set of Alloy's on a new Kia Forte that are exactly what I want for my Niro. I'm not sure if they were 16" or 17" but they were the same design and color.
If you order the 16" Alloy's that fit the Forte everything is the same except the offset. The
OE Niro 16" rim is 6.5Jx16 ET46 with an offset range of 44-48mm and a tire size of tire size: 205/60R16. The
OE Forte 16" rim is 6.5x16 ET50 with an offset range of 48-52mm and a tire size of 205/55R16.
It appears to me that the max. offset on the Niro wheel is 48mm and the minimum offset of the Forte is 48mm, which seems to be compatible.
The issue I have run across is the need to have your odometer (and other systems) calibrated to accommodate the difference in diameter of the 18" and 16" tire sizes. The low profile 18" tire size is 225/45R18 and the desired 16" tire size is 205/60R16.
Googling: 225/45R-18 vs 205/60R-16 you will find the information below:
The difference is the 205 tire vs the 225 tire is
-1.1% less diameter;
-1.1% less circumference;
+21/5% more height;
-1.1% less revolutions per mile;
-8.9% less width.
Speedometer difference with the 205 tire:
20 mph speedo reading vs actual speed 19.78 mph
50 mph speedo reading vs actual speed 49.45 mph
75 mph speedo reading vs actual speed 74.17 mph
100 mph speedo reading vs actual speed 98.89 mph
My conclusion is if you can find a wheel with the correct offset, swapping a 18" 225 with a 16" 205 will work. But don't take my assumption without checking thoroughly with a tire expert, of which I am not.