[kevperro]

I'm considering buying a Niro and wanted to share my thought process. Currently the PHEV with rebate prices out very near to the MSRP of the Hybrid. There is a few dollars here or there different but not enough to change a purchasing decision. No brainer right?

Advantage PHEV

Currently, there are fewer PHEVs available at dealers than hybrids and higher incentives from both the manufacture and dealers in discounting so the Hybrid does enjoy a price benefit. There are also many more in dealer inventory.

Advantage Hybrid

I made up a spreadsheet with some assumptions about price of fuel (always a guess) and MPGs based upon the statistics on Fuelly. I used our inexpensive price of electricity (0.105/Kwh - thank you Cascade Mountains) and ran some simulations based upon my driving habits which are well documented (thank you IRS). The PHEV would save me approx. $19/month at current fuel prices.

Advantage PHEV

Next, I check my local incentives. We live in VERY progressive Seattle and I think to myself, "surely there will be a big fat incentive". Almost.... a tax break which would have saved me paying sales tax on the PHEV just ran out. (Drats!) Then I look more and I find out not only is there no rebate, there is an extra $150/year registration fee for electric vehicles that pretty much erases all benefit of the plug-in! Arg..... what are these legislators thinking?

Advantage Hybrid

At the end of the day I think the availability of the color and options I want will win the day. I'll report once I buy.

 

[npaladin2000]

The Hybrid is also available in more colors. You can't even get a PHEV in red, at all.

Advantage, Hybrid.

Also, in the PHEV, the battery is kind of logically split up. The "hybrid" battery is the same size as in the hybrid. It will only use the extra capacity the PHEV comes with when you charge it via the plug. It'll try to maintain that PHEV-size battery using coasting and regen, but when it's gone, it reverts to a normal hybrid and that extra battery capacity is just dead weight until you get to another outlet.

Advantage, Hybrid.

Hey, at least you being on the west coast have access to the PHEVs. The only ones that make it here to the east coast are a bunch of LXes no one out west wants, and the odd EX that sneaks through. No EX Premiums, not anymore.

 

[kingtermite]

Next, I check my local incentives. We live in VERY progressive Seattle and I think to myself, "surely there will be a big fat incentive". Almost.... a tax break which would have saved me paying sales tax on the PHEV just ran out. (Drats!) Then I look more and I find out not only is there no rebate, there is an extra $150/year registration fee for electric vehicles that pretty much erases all benefit of the plug-in! Arg..... what are these legislators thinking?

I live in the Seattle area too. I just got my PHEV 3 weeks ago (missed the state incentive by even less than you...a week or less).

What is the EV registration fee? I've not heard of this. Got a link?

 

[kingtermite]

OK...found a link. I didn't even know about this.

https://www.king5.com/article/news/local/gas-tax-electric-car-fee-hike-starts-friday/261151663

I see their point, with EVs not paying gas tax, revenue toward transportation issues is reduced, so it does make sense to pay some taxes, but over $10/mo over a year seems very steep.

 

[kevperro]

OK...found a link. I didn't even know about this.



I see their point, with EVs not paying gas tax, revenue toward transportation issues is reduced, so it does make sense to pay some taxes, but over $10/mo over a year seems very steep.

Yea.. the roads have to be paid for. But we are at a stage where electric vehicles are new technology so if you have to incentivize consumers if you want to make progress. Gas taxes make total sense because they are efficient to collect, tax appropriate behavior and are proportional to the actual use of the resource. Taxing good behavior is bad policy, especially when the numbers are inconsequential. Eventually, you have to come up with a replacement for gas taxation but you want the industry to be fully committed before you pump the brakes via taxation and then you want it to make sense based upon use and behavior.

 

[kevperro]

I understand they have to pay for the roads and a gas tax is a perfect mechanism because it incentivizes behavior, is proportion to use and is efficient to collect.

I'd argue that taxing PHEVs is misguided at this point. There isn't enough on the road to represent a significant portion of the use and it is the behavior you want in the population, taxing it is misguided until such time as it becomes accepted and a significant contributor to use.

Then I'd argue the right way to tax it would be via the public charging stations where the tax is proportional to use.

The issues with Washington is because we don't have an income tax, there is no tax that the legislators don't want. If they see something they want to tax it. The tolls on our roads are a complete misuse of transportation assets. They cause accidents, are tax inefficient (much of the tax is used in administration), they cause traffic problems and they are inconsistent in their rules. People from out of town have no idea how to navigate them. I'm not anti-tax nor anti-toll but they are a prime example of why people don't trust the government to manage an asset.

 

[yticolev]

If the best you can do on a PHEV deal is bring it close to MRSP on the HEV, that is a win for the HEV. I got my HEV for $3,000 less than MRSP.

 

[BridgeTripTrapper]

I live in an area where electricity rates are extremely high, about twice what you are paying. But I still love the PHEV, I do nearly all my driving in EV mode and the quiet and smoothness are quite enjoyable. And I like that with the mix of electricity sources in my area the CO2 emissions are lower than an HEV and much lower than a pure ICE.

 

[RedWouldForrest]

In high power/fuel rate areas, the Niro has (for me) been EXTREMELY disappointing. Be aware, there are more efficient choices when paying $4.50+/gal and/or $1+ per Kw/hr.

 

[charlesH]

In high power/fuel rate areas, the Niro has (for me) been EXTREMELY disappointing. Be aware, there are more efficient choices when paying $4.50+/gal and/or $1+ per Kw/hr.

wow, where does one pay $1 per Kwhr?

 

[RedWouldForrest]

Many remote northern California towns are in "Resort Districts", which allows private entities (i.e. the town itself, or a political crony to the town's politicians) to enter into contracts with PG&E and become the local power provider. When this happens, they can charge WHATEVER THEY WANT. And they do.

That's the price some of us pay to live in paradise...

 

[charlesH]

Many remote northern California towns are in "Resort Districts", which allows private entities (i.e. the town itself, or a political crony to the town's politicians) to enter into contracts with PG&E and become the local power provider. When this happens, they can charge WHATEVER THEY WANT. And they do.

That's the price some of us pay to live in paradise...

at $1 per Kwhr neither EV nor PHEV make sense.

$1/3 = $0.33 per mile electric

$5 gas/40 mpg = $0.125 per mile HEV

 

[Sstr Maria]

I like that the PHEV has a 60-HP (44.5 kW) electric motor, 20% more powerful than the Hybrid.

Advantage PHEV

 

[charlesH]

I like that the PHEV has a 60-HP (44.5 kW) electric motor, 20% more powerful than the Hybrid.

Advantage PHEV

True, but just for the record they have the exact same motor.

HEV 125 ft lb 0-1800 rpm (125 x 1800/5200 = 43 HP)

PHEV 125 ft lb 0-2500 rpm (125 x 2500/5200 = 60 HP)

The PHEV motor is rated up to 2500 rpm so that the car can travel at 80+ mph on battery.

 

[yticolev]

My HEV wil go into EV at 75 mph.

 

[charlesH]

My HEV wil go into EV at 75 mph.

Interesting. Are you sure the ICE is not running? What is your max mph on motor alone?

1800 rpm with a 2:1 final drive implies 900 rpm at the wheels. Assuming 800 rpm makes 60 mph 900 rpm implies 68mph. If you are doing 75 then the motor is doing more than 1800 rpm. I assume the motor an exceed 1800 rpm but probable not with 125 ft lb.

I assume the HEV 1800 motor spec at 125 ft lb is a battery current draw limitation. The PHEV, with it larger battery seems capable of a higher power output.

Next time I get a chance, I'll see how fast I can go in ev mode.

 

[yticolev]

The highest mph I've caught it going into EV is 75. But 70 to 73 mph is common and I don't always see it of course if I'm not watching - transition from engine to motor is very smooth engine clutch disengages and engine turns off. Yes, EV mode, mpg is maxed and I can feel and hear when the ICE next engages (not as smooth a transition).

Bear in mind that the motor goes through the full range of the DCT - it is not direct drive. It will still be spinning at 100 mph as it is never disengaged (from spinning anyway). Even at 100 mph, it will be either charging the battery or assisting in torque needs, or in some rare circumstances, electrically neutral.

 

[HybridAtLast]

I'm considering buying a Niro and wanted to share my thought process. Currently the PHEV with rebate prices out very near to the MSRP of the Hybrid. There is a few dollars here or there different but not enough to change a purchasing decision. No brainer right?

Advantage PHEV

Currently, there are fewer PHEVs available at dealers than hybrids and higher incentives from both the manufacture and dealers in discounting so the Hybrid does enjoy a price benefit. There are also many more in dealer inventory.

Advantage Hybrid

I made up a spreadsheet with some assumptions about price of fuel (always a guess) and MPGs based upon the statistics on Fuelly. I used our inexpensive price of electricity (0.105/Kwh - thank you Cascade Mountains) and ran some simulations based upon my driving habits which are well documented (thank you IRS). The PHEV would save me approx. $19/month at current fuel prices.

Advantage PHEV

Next, I check my local incentives. We live in VERY progressive Seattle and I think to myself, "surely there will be a big fat incentive". Almost.... a tax break which would have saved me paying sales tax on the PHEV just ran out. (Drats!) Then I look more and I find out not only is there no rebate, there is an extra $150/year registration fee for electric vehicles that pretty much erases all benefit of the plug-in! Arg..... what are these legislators thinking?

Advantage Hybrid

At the end of the day I think the availability of the color and options I want will win the day. I'll report once I buy.

So, what ever was the final result, and reasoning? I am trying to make the PHEV vs. HEV decision now.
Thanks

 

[ronr9286t]

I'm at the end of a 39 month lease on my Chevy Bolt. After 32,000 trouble-free and enjoyable miles, I'm facing the decision about purchasing the Bolt, getting a new Bolt, or some other vehicle. I'm now retired in AZ, and many of my local trips are short. We also take many road trips. The ability to accomplish the local trips all electric and traveling farther without range-anxiety is enticing. When I was working we drove Mercedes and BMW exclusively, and we switched to Lexus 5 years ago for reliability and maintenance cost. Both Mercedes and BMW have PHEVs, and the BMW is enticing, and I test drove it. It has that BMW driving experience, but then I remembered the reason we switched to Lexus. Lexus will not have their PHEV until 2022, so I looked for an alternative. I read about and then drove the Niro PHEV, and liked it a lot. I'll be getting the Premier with all of the bells and whistles.

It really depends on your use-case. I your regular commute is longer and on the interstate, the hybrid may be the best choice. For me, the PHEV works well.

 

[yticolev]

If you like car sized vehicles, consider the Hyundai Ioniq. Same exact drivetrain, but far more aerodynamic than the Niro so better efficiency. Very rare in the US though, car shaped vehicles are just not that popular. I think the Niro variants outsells the Ioniq by at least 5 to 1. Personally I think it looks better than the Niro but also sort of generic. Another plus is that it costs less. Liftback, so same pluses as your Bolt, but better seats. I needed the Niro shape to haul bicycles and more comfortably car camp, otherwise the Ioniq would have been my choice. Not that you are considering a BEV, but on that car the Ioniq and Niro are very different. The other two variants have identical drivetrains.